Gary Patton's Land Use Reports
Listen to the reports each weekday at 6:49 am & 8:49 am

To suggest a topic for a future land use report, or to convey a comment, please use this link.

Listen to the reports on the audio archive page.

Past Reports

The following Land Use Reports have been presented on KUSP by Gary Patton, Executive Director of The Planning and Conservation League. The opinions expressed by Mr. Patton are not necessarily those of KUSP
Radio, nor of any of its sponsors.


You can contact Gary Patton at PCL by emailing him at: gapatton@pcl.org.

Monday, March 19, 2007 – Big Coastal Project Tomorrow
People who live along East Cliff Drive (that’s in Santa Cruz County) might tell an acquaintance from Boston that they live in “Santa Cruz,” but that’s not actually correct, because “Santa Cruz” is a city, and while West Cliff Drive is in the City of Santa Cruz, East Cliff Drive isn’t.

Both East Cliff and West Cliff are in the County of Santa Cruz, of course, but since West Cliff Drive is located within the boundaries of the City of Santa Cruz, the Santa Cruz City Council makes decisions about developments along West Cliff Drive. East Cliff Drive isn’t in a city, though the City of Capitola is nearby, which means that developments along East Cliff Drive are decided upon by the Santa Cruz County Board of Supervisors.

Most listeners to these regular Land Use Reports probably understand this basic point, but not everyone does, because places that sound like cities sometimes aren’t. Castroville and Prunedale are not cities. Neither are Boulder Creek and Aptos. Decisions about projects in those areas are made by the Monterey County and Santa Cruz County Boards of Supervisors, respectively.

Same for East Cliff Drive. Tomorrow, at its regular meeting, the Santa Cruz County Board of Supervisors will be making some big decisions about the future of East Cliff Drive. If you live in the area, you probably should get informed. Click on the Land Use Report link on the KUSP website for more information about this item.

For KUSP, this is Gary Patton.

More Information
Santa Cruz County Website – http://www.co.santa-cruz.ca.us/
Board of Supervisors Agenda –
http://sccounty01.co.santa-cruz.ca.us/bds/Govstream/ASP/Display/SCCB_AgendaDisplayWeb.asp?MeetingDate=3/20/2007
Agenda Item on Coastal Repair Project –
http://sccounty01.co.santa-cruz.ca.us/bds/Govstream/BDSvData/non_legacy/agendas/2007/20070320/PDF/061.pdf

Tuesday, March 20, 2007 – Latest Decision of the Monterey County Board
Two weeks ago, I noted that decisions by the Monterey County Board of Supervisors were almost certain to cause confusion to voters going to the polls in June.* I’m happy to say that the Board of Supervisors recognized this, and promptly scheduled a time to discuss what they should do about it. During their meeting last week, on March 13th, the Board did, in fact, address the problem. Their decision, however, was not to eliminate the confusion, but to perpetuate it.

Because of action by concerned voters, both an initiative measure and a referendum measure are now going to appear on the June ballot. The Board did everything it could to prevent the voters from getting to the ballot with the initiative and referendum, but they lost that battle. The Constitutional right of the voters to use their initiative and referendum powers ultimately prevailed.

Faced with that reality, the Board placed its own measure on the ballot, and that is where the confusion comes from. The Board’s measure asks voters if they want to “repeal” the Board’s GPU4 Plan (which isn’t even in effect, because of the referendum). On the other two measures, “Yes” means “Yes,” and “No” means “No,” but the Board’s measure is structured so that a “No” vote is a vote in favor of the Board’s plan.

Because of the Board’s action, part of its continuing battle to make sure that the voters don’t get a fair chance to decide what they want, those supporting the Community General Plan are going to have to go back to court.

For KUSP, this is Gary Patton.

More Information
*You can review the transcript of the March 5, 2007 Land Use Report at –
http://www.landwatch.org/pages/kusp2007/030507kusp.html#monday

Monterey County Website – http://www.co.monterey.ca.us/
County of Monterey General Plan Update - http://www.co.monterey.ca.us/pbi/gpu/
LandWatch Monterey County Website - http://www.landwatch.org/
Community General Plan Website – http://www.montereyplan.org/

Voter confusion is not just a “hypothesis.” The “Big Question” a recent edition of the Salinas Californian asked, “Do you find the three general plan measures on June’s ballot confusing?” While the sample size was small, the results were clear: 85% of the respondents said “YES.” -
http://www.thecalifornian.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20070301/NEWS01/703010319/1002

Wednesday, March 21, 2007 – A Tale of Two Neighborhoods
Citizen activism on land use matters is a “taken for granted” reality in the City of Santa Cruz. As you can imagine, I think that’s a great thing, and one of the best things about living in Santa Cruz. Every community should be so lucky!

I first got involved in citizen activism as a member of the Save Lighthouse Point Association, back in the early 1970’s, and from that time to this, local residents in the City of Santa Cruz have regularly become involved, directly, in the land use and related decisions that so profoundly affect their future. My weekday Land Use Reports are an invitation for you to get involved in your local community (no matter where you live), and to see if you don’t agree that one of the most satisfying experiences we can have in life is joining together with friends and neighbors to help make the future be what we think it should be, instead of letting things just “happen to us.” I can get almost rhapsodic about the joys of “self government,” the kind of government in which we get involved ourselves.

If you are a resident on the Eastside of the City of Santa Cruz, you should know that concerned residents, calling themselves the Seabright Neighbors, are working hard to expand the Frederick Street Park. If you live on the Westside of the City, you may be interested in “Friends of the Westside,” a group that is working against a large new Bus and Maintenance Yard, proposed on Swift Street.

For KUSP, this is Gary Patton.

More Information
Seabright Neighbors Website - http://www.rootaction.org/170FrederickSt.html
More information on the Frederick Street Park issue from – spitzer@cruzio.com

Bus Yard Petition – http://www.ipetitions.com/petition/smart_planning_now/
More information on Friends of the Westside - neighbors@westsidefriends.com

Thursday, March 22, 2007 – The PCL Symposium
These Land Use Reports focus on the Monterey Bay Area and the Central Coast, providing a “heads up” on significant land use items. My “day job,” however, finds me not on the Central Coast, but in Sacramento, where I head the Planning and Conservation League. PCL works on all sorts of environmental issues at the state level.

Today, I thought I’d provide you with a special invitation to attend PCL’s 2007 Environmental Legislative Symposium, scheduled for Saturday, April 14th, at the Sacramento Convention Center. You can get full information on the Symposium by clicking on the Land Use Report link at www.kusp.org.

The PCL Symposium is not just for those who follow state level issues. Quite the opposite. PCL is truly a League” of local environmental organizations, and the Symposium is our annual statewide “get together,” where local groups share their experiences and efforts, and learn from each other. This year, the Symposium is entitled, “How To…Win The Environmental Battles That Test This Generation.”

Workshops will include instruction on how to enforce legal rights and government obligations under California’s “Government in the Sunshine” laws, how to run a community initiative, how to use the California Environmental Quality Act, and how to run a successful referendum. Attorneys can even get MCLE credit!

For KUSP, this is Gary Patton.

More Information
The Planning and Conservation League Website – www.pcl.org
The 2007 Symposium Program - http://www.pcl.org/projects/2007symposium/agenda.html
Online registration for the Symposium - https://secure.ga1.org/05/07symposium

If you would like to become a subscriber to the PCL “Insider,” a weekly bulletin on key environmental issues, written from the State Capital, visit our website at - http://action.nwf.org/pcl/home.html

Friday, March 23, 2007 – Learn About the Farm Bureau’s Views
Bob Perkins is the Executive Director of the Monterey County Farm Bureau, and is an outspoken opponent of the Community General Plan initiative that will be on the Monterey County ballot in June. Mr. Perkins is also a spokesperson for those who would like to change the California Constitution, to make it more difficult for local governments to use the power of eminent domain. During last November’s election, Mr. Perkins was urging a “yes” vote on Proposition 90, which would not only have restricted the ability of local governments to use eminent domain, but would also have required the government to “pay” property owners if the government tried to restrict their use of their property. Most of our land use regulations do, in fact, restrict what property owners can do with their property, and Mr. Perkins thinks the community’s ability to impose such restrictions should be radically curtailed. To place his views in context, Governor Schwarzenegger opposed (not supported) Proposition 90 last November.

Whatever your own views on these issues, you might like to have a chance to hear what a strong “property rights” proponent has to say about them. Your chance to do that is coming up, at a March 28th luncheon sponsored by the Monterey Bay Republican Women Federated. Their meeting will be at the Embassy Suites Hotel in Seaside. You can send me an email with your comments and suggestions.

For KUSP, this is Gary Patton.

More Information
Monterey County Farm Bureau Website - http://www.montereycountyfarmbureau.org/
Monterey Bay Republican Women Federated Website - http://www.mbrwf.org/
Information on the March 28th luncheon - http://www.mbrwf.org/event.htm
For reservations, you can call 831-375-3573. Cost is $20 per person.